Overview of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s Speech
Martin Luther King’s speech, delivered around 61 years ago in Washington. King illustrated the injustices black Americans endured in the US and their fight for freedom, independence, and equality using themes widely recognized by all. King says, “I have a dream,” at the beginning of nearly every line of his speech (Rare Facts, 2017). The speaker repeated his wish that black and white Americans would eventually enjoy equal rights and that all kids would have the chance to pursue their education and grow up to be decent adults.
Overview of Alicia Garza’s Speech
Alicia Garza begins her speech by citing data, including the pay gap between Black and White women, the number of Black people killed by law enforcement officers, and the number of incarcerated Black men and women (Center for Constitutional Rights [CCR], 2015). She illustrates the struggles and injustices that Black people encounter throughout her speech. She demonstrates the critical role that the Black Lives Matter (BLM) Movement had in eradicating inequality. Garza’s presentation demonstrates that discrimination against Black people persists globally. She provides instances of predominantly African American women who were compelled, frequently against their will, to work as domestic helpers (CCR, 2015).
Comparing Leadership, Charisma, and Impact
Martin Luther King Jr.’s Leadership and Charisma
King was overly charismatic and passionate when he delivered his address to his extensive audience. He used his charisma and passion to inspire hope among many people who attended his oration. King’s leadership was also effective in influencing his audience to listen to the message of his address. As one of the most revered Black leaders during that period, many of King’s followers felt moved and encouraged by his words of wisdom. He had demonstrated his ability to lead many times over in diverse black communities around the nation. This gave him the power to influence multitudes to conform to champion freedom.
Alicia Garza’s Style and Influence
Garza also seemed passionate in delivering her address to those in attendance. However, compared to King, Garza seemed less charismatic and powerful. This is because using a social networking avenue to inspire followers rarely grants any one individual the influence it did on King at the Lincoln Memorial. This Martin Luther King and Alicia Garza speech comparison highlights not only their rhetorical styles but also how their leadership approaches differed based on era, audience, and platforms.
Role of Speech Locations in Delivering the Message
Importance of Location in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Speech
The presentations of the two talks were delivered in disparate settings because of the extensive disparity between their timelines of delivery. The differences elicited by both settings comprised the size of the crowds and their ability to see the orators. On the one hand, King’s oration was attended by many people compared to those who attended Garza’s talks (Rare Facts, 2017). However, the audience at his oration was unable to see him. Seeing the speaker making an address is crucial to relaying messages effectively to an audience.
Impact of Venue on Alicia Garza’s Address
In contrast, Garza’s address was given in a comparatively small venue (CCR, 2015). This made it possible for all those in attendance to see her, her gestures, and her emotions. The orators were able to act differently since they gave their presentations in two distinct settings. Garza’s setting made it possible for her to use her gestures and facial expressions to relay her message to the audience. King, on the other hand, had to use the tone of his voice and the content of his speech to impact those in attendance emotionally.
Does Messaging Make a Difference?
Yes. Messaging makes a difference because social networking sites can reach more people compared to traditional events attended by people.
Audience Comparison: Then and Now
Similarities in Audience Response
Both speakers paint a comprehensive picture of the disparity between whites and blacks in American culture, suggesting they aimed their speeches at similar audiences. Additionally, the audiences in both cases respond emotionally to the orators, showing strong enthusiasm for supporting the core themes presented in each speech. Overall, this Martin Luther King and Alicia Garza speech comparison reveals how each speaker responded to the racial injustices of their time using unique but equally powerful voices.
Differences in Audience Focus
Garza’s address is more focused on a specific topic, though, since it mostly discusses the BLM movement, which she founded by stating a few widely known statistical estimates (CCR, 2015). King’s speech, on the other hand, does not specifically target any movement. Rather, it aims to paint a whole picture of the struggles and obstacles that Black people in the US face.
We Are Available 24 hours To Serve you
Need help with your coursework or academic essay?
